Bands or Artists who used to be punk

Three huge ones-
Jerry's Kids
Gang Green
Danzig

Also, Bob Mould from Hüsker Dü

 

the music gets worse and the bullshit they talked comes out like a stain, they say change i say sellout, movin on, i know what it doeth.

 

I love Henry Rollin's spoken word stuffs. Great.

Chumbawamba anyone???

Social Distortion

Misfits in general, I hate everything after Danzig left.

 

I wouldn't say bad brains sold out as much as they just moved on to reggae

 

A few I can think of off the top of my head

Butthole Surfers
T.S.O.L.
D.R.I.
Corrosion of Conformity (great disappointment there)
Suicidal Tendencies
Circle Jerks

And hell yes I agree with you on the Misfits post danzig, I mean come on the WW fucking E!
But I feel i should defend Joy Division, they didn't sell out New Order did. They're first ep was released on a major but the rest were on Factory or Strange fruit records then after the vocalist offed himself and they became New Order they went to shit.

And is the music they wrote before the aforementioned selling out still credible?
I believe so.
One thing to keep in mind is most times the band ends up getting screwed by the "BIG" record company in the end.
Poetic justice you could say huh.

 

I think that if a band that includes anarchist/anti-capitalist though in their lyrics sign to a major label then it is a contradiction.

I feel that as anti-capitalists it is hard to not be a part of the system in some way, we all have to buy things to live (unless you live self-sufficiently, which isn't possible for everyone) but music and art in general is still something we have control of, in essence it is ours and I don't think that we should allow it to be complicit in a wider oppressive system.

I don't have any bands to add unfortunately...although I could add Billy Bragg (I know he was never punk, but at least his mindset was) since he gave up his socialist roots in favour of the liberal demoncrats in the UK.

 

the guy from koro

 

d.r.i.????? what about them

 

Okay I think that if you "used to be a punk" then you never were a punk. So just because a band played punk sounding music does that make them a true punk band?

Green Day started off on Look Out records, and played pop-punk... but were they ever truly a punk band? For that matter Blink 182 just because they play punk sounding music does it make them punk? If it does make them punk then I guess Avril would be a punk huh...

So what about Chumbawamba, they started off playing "punk" music then they did pop-music, and now they do folk music but did they ever stop being a punk band?

Does signing to a major make you an un-punk band? The Damned, The Ramones, Stiff Little Fingers, Adam and the Ants.... the list goes on all on majors, so were they not punk bands?

So what makes a punk band, and how can a band not be one anymore?

 

i still think joy division is the shit lol but yeah i agree with selling out after ian curtis died new order to me sounds like shit!

 

CONFLICT
Bad Religion
NOFX
Casualties

and some others

 

Er Minor Threat...
Although Ians other stuff is good, I just don't know if it's "punk"

 

Fugazi was punk in the original extent of the word

 

I see what you're trying to say, but listening to minor threat then fugazi is like....well in your words, "slayer to sonny and cher"

 

just wanted to clear up: you can be a punk and not a puritanical anarchist eh but they are quite closely aligned, punk was a form of anarchy before anarchy got reborn in the 80's which is great as it never went away just been kicked a few times by consecutive 'great' wars(closed media, closed though, closed rights.......), thats whay they keep avin em, they don't want you to have peace and freedom so take it