Loading...
Welcome to Anarcho-Punk.net community ! Please register or login to participate in the forums.   Ⓐ//Ⓔ

favorite anarchistic philosopher

Discussion in 'Anarchism and radical activism' started by stinagen, Apr 18, 2010.

  1. stinagen

    stinagen Experienced Member Experienced member


    64

    0

    0

    Dec 6, 2009
     
    can we get back to the subject this has turned into a war
     
  2. ungovernable

    ungovernable Autonome Staff Member Uploader Admin Team Experienced member


    4,423

    119

    24

    Aug 21, 2009
    Male
    Canada  Canada
    it's still expressing yourself

    and my argument is still true: the anarchists have the right to "deface building", but not their ennemies.

    It's called "à l'extrême-droite du père" a documentary by "les infiltrés"

    available here:
    http://forums.resistance.tk/message.php?t=8529

    but no, only in french...

    wtf you are going to tell me that this is sexist again ? what the hell, everything is interpreted as sexism in english ??

    the exact same sentence translated in french have absolutly no sexist meaning, it just means "you don't have the courage to"


    Once again you don't like your ideas to me confronted so you will just ignore me yeah i knew it...

    BULLSHIT ! You called me a fascist and an authoritarian multiple times, so fuck you !

    Oh ok, so calling you an asshole is different than insulting you of being a fascist, a stalinist or an authoritarian... mmmmhh okay...

    lol you prove once again that you probably never took part into an anarchist organisation of any kind, because you wouldn't say there's only one of me.

    all anarchists here and in france are all radically anti-fascist and they would all react the same if you start telling them they act like fascists because they dont believe in freedom of speech for fascism, racism, and nazism.

    I also noticed most of the peoples who defend this point of view are american or british... looks like you all been brainwashed by the politics of USA regarding the tolerance towards nazism and you think that this is true freedom, anyway you already said that the USA is a free country, one of the best place to live! So yes, you are ignorant and brainwashed
     
  3. Spider

    Spider Experienced Member Experienced member


    90

    1

    0

    Sep 3, 2009
     
    Our government in Australia is currently looking to put in place a filter on our internet, restricting any content which is refused classification. They won't tell us what websites are being blocked but assure us it's "for our own good" and most supporters are claiming things like child pornography etc. are the main reason. There will probably be nazi sites which get blocked by this filter, but also more than likely there will be anarchist sites as well because we all know the general ignorant opinion of anarchy held by most braindead politicians. Would you say this was authoritarian ungovernable?? or because some of what is being hidden from us is nazi based does that make it ok?? should i stop protesting and undermining these plans because the spanish revolution banned franquist propaganda therefore all censorship of non anarchist material is kosher??????
     
  4. ungovernable

    ungovernable Autonome Staff Member Uploader Admin Team Experienced member


    4,423

    119

    24

    Aug 21, 2009
    Male
    Canada  Canada
    wow.... you are ridiculous

    in my previous posts on this topic i already said that censoring internet would be fucking stupid, EVEN FOR NAZIS SITES

    and i never ever said we should censor other things than fascism and nazis. i would never support censorship of the internet that include censoring anarchist website, of course i'm against australia censorship program, that's a fucking stupid question!!

    the spanish revolution never used such manners, and never censored other things than the fascists, your argument is totally off-topic
     
  5. Bakica

    Bakica Experienced Member Experienced member Forum Member


    951

    0

    0

    Feb 21, 2010
     
    I just want to say that not everyones a 100% anarchist so what if he denies something? hes now worhless?thats stupid. ungovernm. just ask yourself are you a fucking awsome super good person? and do you understand the whole thing about anarchy? And are you just a mortal man typing some shit on the Internet or do you realy do some things in real life?
     
  6. ungovernable

    ungovernable Autonome Staff Member Uploader Admin Team Experienced member


    4,423

    119

    24

    Aug 21, 2009
    Male
    Canada  Canada
    Yes i do.

    Yes i really do some things in real life, much more than you might think. I have experience, and that's why i say NGNM85 probably never took part in a real-life anarchist organisation or any anarchist project, or else he would understand that we can't tolerate freedom of speech for the nazis. I learnt that with experiance, a couple of years ago i was almost at the same point as NGNM85 (but not as ridiculous as him) and i believed that we should tolerate freedom of speech for the nazis so peoples dont think we are contradictory. I was like him and i thought i was so cool, a superhero fighting for freedom of speech with super revolutionary ideas.... Then i realized that in pratice, it is something else completly different and that i must review my ideas to be realistic. I also learnt that it is a total contradiction with anarchist history.

    So i evolved and changed my ideas.
     
  7. back2front

    back2front Experienced Member Experienced member


    95

    0

    0

    Nov 26, 2009
     
    In anarchism we have a concept called direct democracy; it's where everyone is given the option to speak on issues which directly affect them. It is one of the central tenets of anarchism since the days of Bakunin. Considering that the vast majority of people who come onto these boards are either anarchists or learning about anarchism then we might consider each other comrades and offer each other the hand of respect, listen to what each other has to say and learn from each other. Anarchist ideas are about freedom after all. Not to say we can't argue our corners, and fiercely, but that we might do so in an atmosphere of respect. This is an aspect of what we call mutual aid.

    Therefore I would like to make a public apology for the embarrassment caused by the misrepresentation of anarchist ideas by one very angry young man on these boards. For those of you looking in this is not the way we generally conduct ourselves and should not be seen as representative of anarchist debate. Anyone who behaves like a bully in our anarchist group is asked to leave or thrown out so my suggestion is that we ignore the internet warriors here until they can climb down off their high horse and learn to have a little bit of RESPECT.
     
  8. ungovernable

    ungovernable Autonome Staff Member Uploader Admin Team Experienced member


    4,423

    119

    24

    Aug 21, 2009
    Male
    Canada  Canada
    So what if we decide through direct democracy to NOT allow nazi hate propaganda ? (which WILL happen because an anarchist community tolerating nazi propaganda would be fucking stupid) You will still say that we are authoritarian and fascists ?

    Ahahahahahaha

    ok first i'm an anarchist since 10 years so shut up i know way enough, my age doesn't matter and you are the living proof that there is no age to be stupid and ignorant

    second, you should also make public apology for the misrepresentation of anarchist ideas in the last 100 years. All examples of anarchist revolutions were doing the exact same thing as me, they disagree to give freedom of speech for the nazis.

    third, there are serious anarchist theoricians who have the triple of my age and who still believe we shouldnt give freedom of speech for the nazis

    YOU are the one who misrepresent anarchism, i know for sure (and by experience) that the VAST MAJORITY of anarchists are strongly anti-fascist and disapprove any kind of freedom of speech for the fascists. America might be an exception, a lot of anarchists are stupid there. But just go ask on any french forum, and everyone will laught at you if you start talking about giving freedom of speech to our ennemies !!

    Saying that it's not the way we conduct ourselves is a lies, i have said many times that you CANNOT FIND A SINGLE HISTORICAL EXAMPLE WHERE FREE SPEECH FOR THE NAZIS WAS TOLERATED.

    You are really funny, contradictory and hypocritical jackass.

    In the same phrase you call me an internet warrior and then you talk about respect.

    Fuck you, because i'm talking to you on internet doesn't means i'm an internet warrior, you know NOTHING of me and if you knew me in real life you wouldn't say i'm an internet warrior, so shut the fuck up.

    You talk about direct democracy and that everyone should be given the right to speak, then you say we should all ignore me. Fucking contradictory hypocrite !!! At least I let you talk and i consider your arguments.
     
  9. AnarchoFem

    AnarchoFem Experienced Member Experienced member Forum Member


    155

    6

    0

    Apr 15, 2010
     
    I completely agree with you back2front. I am new to these boards and was shocked and horrified by some people's instant bad-mouthing and judging. Ungovernable, although I agree with you on what you're saying re:free speech, I think the way you treat other anarchists and other PEOPLE on this board and the sexist words you choose to use is completely disrespectful. At the end of the day many people are here to learn and you're not setting a very good environment in which this can happen my immediately resorting to insults, instead of politely arguing your point.

    My mistake...politeness is for the beourgeoisie...isn't it?!
     
  10. ungovernable

    ungovernable Autonome Staff Member Uploader Admin Team Experienced member


    4,423

    119

    24

    Aug 21, 2009
    Male
    Canada  Canada
    I don't give a fuck of what you are saying since you can't say the same thing for NGNM85 and his friends.

    I was insulted since the begginning, i was called an authoritarian, i was called a fascist, i was called a stalinist, i was called a fake anarchist, etc... So YES, i lost all respect and politeness i have for this idiot who insult me. I never insulted the first. I always do this, if you are polite with me i will be polite with you. But don't expect me to keep respecting you if you call me a fascist, an authoritarian and a stalinist, etc...

    Also if you are not happy, nobody force you to stay here, thanks.
     
  11. AnarchoFem

    AnarchoFem Experienced Member Experienced member Forum Member


    155

    6

    0

    Apr 15, 2010
     
    Why do you have to be so childish ungovernable. Even if you were insulted first, does that mean you have to stoop to their level?

    And I will definitely stay here ungovernable, because there are plenty of people asides from you with whom I can have a debate that doesn't resort to personal attacks and insults.
     
  12. ungovernable

    ungovernable Autonome Staff Member Uploader Admin Team Experienced member


    4,423

    119

    24

    Aug 21, 2009
    Male
    Canada  Canada
    I lose my patience when i get insulted. It's one of my bad point.

    But the argument was that you critize me because i insult, but you don't critize the others who insulted me. Why are you being so unfair ?
     
  13. AnarchoFem

    AnarchoFem Experienced Member Experienced member Forum Member


    155

    6

    0

    Apr 15, 2010
     
    I would definitely have said that to anybody else had I noticed it, but I didn't notice anybody else resorting to insults like "you're so stupid", "you pussy", "you don't have the balls" except from you. But please feel free to post quotes from what other people said to you. I apologise if I am mistaken.

    I dont think insults like that should appear here, not just from you Ungovernable but from anyone, please remember who your real enemies are.

    It is ironic that I have to tell you Ungovernable (a moderator) to take a look at the Points of Unity that you so frequently point out to others:

    "In all debates, please always pay attention to mutual respect and stay polite while avoiding personal attacks. Fighting each other will lead us nowhere."
     
  14. ungovernable

    ungovernable Autonome Staff Member Uploader Admin Team Experienced member


    4,423

    119

    24

    Aug 21, 2009
    Male
    Canada  Canada
    Just before you started your ranting, you had an insult right above: someone calling me a fake anarchist and an internet warrior. Stop pretending you didn't see it. On the other topic you posted into just before this one, NGNM85 is insulting another member and telling him "fuck you"

    Read this whole thread, and you will see that i got insulted by many peoples a couple of time. It's normal that i lose my patience

    As for the sexist insults, i don't even knew it was considered as sexism in english. And it's fucking stupid, when i say something like "you don't have the balls" that's just saying "you are not making a man of yourself". And don't tell me this last one is also sexist because you can also say "make a woman of yourself".

    Anyway, in french it is definatly not considered as sexism, and even the feminist use insults like "you don't even have the balls" or "make a man of yourself".

    What part of "I RESPECT THE PEOPLES WHO RESPECT ME - DON'T INSULT ME AND I WILL NOT INSULT YOU" you don't understand ??

    Respect isn't only one way. If i get hit on the cheek i will not show the other cheek to get hit again.

    Start by teachning lessons to peoples who started this fight, because i seriously don't care about your rantings.


    Also, you only quote the part of the text that you like, eh ?

    It also says:

    It this point was respected we would have avoided this whole stupid debate.
     
  15. AnarchoFem

    AnarchoFem Experienced Member Experienced member Forum Member


    155

    6

    0

    Apr 15, 2010
     
    Calling somebody a "fake anarchist" based on behaviour that anarchists would oppose isn't what I would call an insult. Just as much if I was calling somebody a "pussy" and someone called me a fake feminist. It would be true. However, calling somebody stupid because you disagree is completely different. That is just a personal, unnecessary attack.

    I am shocked you keep bringing up the sexist insults..."Make a man of yourself", because that's what EVERYBODY should try and do is it? That's what the ideal goal is??? To make men of ourselves??? Not just GOOD PEOPLE. Yes that is sexist. No need to keep repeating it, I (and I'm sure everyone else who was insulted by this) would accept a simple apology. And regarding it not being sexist in French, most people don't realise it is sexist in English either. I wouldn't use that as an excuse.

    Yes i agree respect should be mutual, but Ungovernable you were the one who started the personal insults. Like i have already said, calling somebody a "fake anarchist" is legitimate if that person is behaving CONSISTENTLY in a manner that anarchists would not. It is quite clear you do not like being confronted about this, but I am glad that somebody has finally brought it up.

    And no, I didn't see NGNM say "fuck you" in another topic, but if it makes you feel better Ungovernable, I will mention it there too.
     
  16. ungovernable

    ungovernable Autonome Staff Member Uploader Admin Team Experienced member


    4,423

    119

    24

    Aug 21, 2009
    Male
    Canada  Canada
    i see no difference between political insults and traditionnal insult. To me, being called a fascist and an internet warrior is definatly an insult.

    if you prefer i will insult him of being a nazi, a fascist and a stalinist if you prefer, but then you will still say i'm not being polite.

    Calling me a fascist and an authoritarian is also personal and unnecessary, it is definatly not productive and objective for the debate

    I didn't use those words again since i was told it was interpreted as sexism. Stop making a big drama for no reason.

    You tell "make a man of yourself" to a man, and "make a woman of yourself" to a woman. No that's definatly not sexist, at least not in french. Even feminist use this sentence. It just means "get up and be strong" we could say "make a real person of yourself" and it would mean the same thing. It's definatly not sexist

    I never used this word as an insult again, now we are just talking about the meaning of the word. Don't start to act like a feminist-fascist and try to censor everything, i'm just talking about the meaning of the word, not using it as an insult.

    Anyway don't forget, sexism is what some peoples on this forum would call "freedom of speech" ;)

    No i didn't start the personal insults, you are lying.

    I'm not acting consistently in a manner that anarchists would not, i have repeated many times that ALL ANARCHISTS OF THE HISTORY acted the SAME WAY. And in 11 pages of debates, nobody was able to prove me wrong.

    So i'm acting in the same manner that all anarchists act since 100 years. NGNM85 and his supporters are the one who are not.

    Yes please teach him lessons like you do for me, and argue during 5 posts to prove how he is a bad guy.

    Also say the same thing to the other 3-4 peoples who also insulted me in this topic.
     
  17. AnarchoFem

    AnarchoFem Experienced Member Experienced member Forum Member


    155

    6

    0

    Apr 15, 2010
     
    I'm acting like a feminist-fascist???!!! LMAO! Because I asked you to apologise?? Which you still haven't by the way.
    And yes Ungovernable,I seriously have my doubts that you say "be a woman", but i'll take your word for it, but you still shouldn't...don't assume anybody's gender. It would make a lot more sense in my opinion to say "be a person"...

    Ungovernable, I'm not going to "say the same thing" to everybody that you feel personally insulted by. Why don't you go "be a man" and do it yourself.
    I'm speaking GENERALLY when I say to people, stop with the insults.

    And what "same manner" as all anarchists? Regarding freespeech for Nazis yes...but all anarchists for the past 100 years have been rude??? How so?? Because that is what I was referring to.
     
  18. Anom

    Anom Experienced Member Experienced member Forum Member


    698

    0

    0

    Dec 21, 2009
     
    @anyone who wants to read it...
    Hey chill a bit now, will you?
    Ok, i didn't fancy it when someone was called a pussy but to question one person here for questioning if someone has balls as a metaphore, just doesn't seem right when in almost every single thread in this entire forum there is someone saying the same thing or calling someone a dick or something like that. It's not the same person that does this all the time so if critique for this should go out to anyone it should be to pretty much everyone here. I have myself earlier in this thread gotten the existance of my balls questioned as you might have seen and this was by a completely different person.
    Now i might perhaps seem sexist to some of you but i find it way less offensive being called let's say a pussy by another woman then by a man and i imagine the same might go for men calling eachother dicks, right? I can't really concider it to be offensive if a woman points out to me that i have the same bodyparts as she does.
     
  19. Protspecd

    Protspecd Experienced Member Experienced member Forum Member


    466

    0

    0

    Mar 3, 2010
     
    I am sorry, but if we go back to the Exploited thread, you will see this is not the case. I did not call you names if I remember correctly but in many of your replies you insulted me quite a bit. I may have to check my arguments again but I don't think I ever insulted you, in fact I was fairly polite about the whole debate. Though I may have misunderstood your posts and misread some parts, there was no reason for you to constantly insult me throughout the argument. Maybe my memory is wrong.
     
  20. butcher

    butcher Experienced Member Uploader Experienced member Forum Member


    2,118

    2

    18

    Sep 8, 2009
     
    considering the context, ie ungovernable arguing that we need to smash fascist organisations, and the subsequent barrage of insults, in the form of 'authoritarian', 'fake-anarchist' or 'stalinist', I would say that Ungovernable has every right to be completely fucked off and frustrated. These are fairly serious insults, not only as an attempt to hurt Ungovernable, but in that they show a serious misunderstanding of anarchism. Whilst i do not congratulate Ungovernable on his use of sexist language i would tend to argue that, considering the context, its an error on his behalf but hardly the worst thing ever.

    I find interwebz forum etiquette to be somewhat strange at times, it tends to be moar like a uni tutorial then a union meeting, which is rather interesting for a working class movement. For those of you with experience in union organising, you'll no doubt be well familiar with the rather crude (and un-PC) use of language employed by Ungovernable at times. This is not necessarily a bad thing.
     
Loading...