Loading...
Welcome to Anarcho-Punk.net community ! Please register or login to participate in the forums.   Ⓐ//Ⓔ

Religous views

Discussion in 'General Discussion' started by colton_and, Apr 16, 2010.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. ungovernable

    ungovernable Autonome Staff Member Uploader Admin Team Experienced member


    4,423

    119

    24

    Aug 21, 2009
    Male
    Canada  Canada
    it's called a point of view. a debate forum is meant for opposing your ideas against other people's ideas. i have the right to not agree when i see something contradictory.

    why don't you tell Ring of truth that he doesn't have to call me a fascist, a dictator, an ignorant and such just because he doesn't agree with me ?

    No gods, no masters, no paganism bullshit.
     
  2. Axehandle Mountain

    Axehandle Mountain Active Member Forum Member


    41

    0

    0

    Feb 26, 2010
     
    You're just being rude and refusing to consider any opinion other than your own, regardless of facts. You haven't really provided any arguments, only senseless proclamations that you refuse to back with logical explanation. You've contributed nothing to this discussion, and resort to copying articles instead of personal revelation and logic. That's not intelligent debate, that's just typical self-righteous internet anarchist behavior.

    Carry on screaming and fist-shaking, I'm just going to ignore any encounters we may have in the future.
     
  3. ungovernable

    ungovernable Autonome Staff Member Uploader Admin Team Experienced member


    4,423

    119

    24

    Aug 21, 2009
    Male
    Canada  Canada
    lol i have wrote endless posts, i gave links, copied articles, and you say i didn't bring any arguments. Yet you're the one who makes four-lines-posts and never brought up real arguments.

    I already gave my own opinion, and if i don,t back up my arguments with famous anarchist arguments you will say i'm a dictator and a fascist, so i'm copying those articles to explain that atheism is a majoritary point of view in anarchism. So either we are all fascists, or you guys are just dumb and ignorant.

    Go back worshiping your god and reading how to act and what to do through books and religious cults, you're not better than a christian worshipping his bible.

    You ignored my whole messages, you said nothing against the articles i posted just like you ignored my links. A debate with you is a waste of time, you're not even capable of reading and questionning yourself because you are sure to be right (typically religious, a debate with a christian would be the same than a debate with you)

    Keep ignoring my arguments like a good and well domesticated believer. Follow your cult and don't question yourself.
     
  4. Ring Of Truth

    Ring Of Truth Experienced Member Experienced member Forum Member


    201

    0

    4

    Dec 28, 2009
     
    It's funny how you accuse me of being a pagan, just because I understand it's concept. And about atheism I just think it's funny that people throw the term around yet don't understand it's true meaning, what you refer to is religious atheism, which I can understand but don't totally buy into. I don't see how religion has much to do with anything.

    Ungovernable I never insulted you, I pointed out how your actions were sounding, which to me should only sound like an accusation if it ha some truth to it.

    I think it's funny how you think only in absolutes, that there is no gray areas only your opinions. Like I have said before I respect difference of opinion, and I respect that you and I disagree. But you know it is a big world out there, and if you actually expect the world to exist with no religious beliefs, then you are in for a major disappointment. What we need people to understand is that people can be free to believe in what they wish as long as it is not imposing upon others, and as long as they don't have to kill anyone for it. If you try to take away peoples right to believe in something then there will be a lot of deaths wars and nothing will change, that is why most of the worlds wars already exist.

    I agree that religion is one of the biggest plagues of man kind, but you must understand that it will be nearly impossible for the world to not have beliefs what-so-ever.

    You said a lot of other stuff that I don't see worth my time responding to.

    But one other thing you said that I said... man this is pointless... but anyway... I asked if the stress of needing a new server might be putting you on edge, because I want to understand why you have been so irate lately when you weren't in your earlier posts months ago. And if you don't want people to donate to help you out why is there things all over the site asking people to, and if you want people to bad enough to put things all over the site asking people to, then why are you needlessly bashing people on the forum... I mean shouldn't you be a good example?

    I don't have anything against you, I really don't, and on many things I agree with you, but to call someone stupid or a nazi because they believe in something is out of line, and then to get pissed off like big cry baby when people point it out is even worse. Why can't you admit that you don't know shit about paganism, and that you had a bad experience, which is why you responded the way you did. But no you put generalizations on things and apply a small minority group to billions of people world wide. That is like saything that because Hitler was a Jew that all Jews are nazi (can you see how retarded of an arguement that you make?).

    I don't really see a point in continuing in this debate. Also if you think you have bashed my beliefs in all this you haven't since you haven't even bothered to ask why mine are.

    Oh also you are anti-racist, and hate anyone that seems to show any racism... did you realize that one of the biggest critisizisms of Emma Goldman is that she is racist... which though I love her writing and a lot of her ideals, I am often times cautious to quote her... just saw irony in that and thought I would mention it.

    There is a time and a place for everything, and to abolish religion all-together will take a lot of patience and understanding, you must nurture people to your side not beat them into believing you are correct.
     
  5. ungovernable

    ungovernable Autonome Staff Member Uploader Admin Team Experienced member


    4,423

    119

    24

    Aug 21, 2009
    Male
    Canada  Canada
    Where did you see this?

    You're the one who totally doesn't understand the meaning of atheism. If we're all ignorant then please explain me why the majority of anarchist philosphers are atheists??

    Now you are lying. You said multiple times that i'm not anarchist, that i'm a fascist, in a revolution i would become the dictator, etc etc. Of course you insulted me.

    Paganism is not a gray area when we're talking about religions, it's a RELIGION.

    Yeah right, how do you respect other opinions when having a different opinion makes you a fascist, a dictator, a fake anarchist, etc ?

    So what ? I'm still against it. I'm not going to force anybody to follow me except the organized religion lumpenproletariat.

    Does it also include peoples who are against religion ?

    You say that everyone is free to believe in what they wish but if someone believe that ALL religions are shit you say he's a fascist and a dictator. You're so contradictory.

    Most of the wars also exist because of religions / religious wars

    People's intention to donate shouldn't be influenced by the opinions of ONE member of a community counting thousands of members, i really don't see your point. I'm just the webmaster, you know... the tech guy. Nothing else. And no i'm not going to not say what i think just to get money in return.

    By the way almost no one donated so i really care less about agreeing with what i don't agree just to get money. It's a capitalist way of thinking. Money shouldn't influence the speech.

    LIES.

    I never called anobody a nazi, it's an INVENTION of your's.

    Provide sources and evidences or shut up.

    You don't have anything against me ? You just called me a dictator, a fake anarchist, a fascist, you say i lost all your respect, blah blah blah

    I know a lot about paganism and i have read a lot about it, i have pointed out some texts but you ignored them all. First time i hears about paganism was MANY years ago.

    And maybe YOU should admit that you don't know shit about atheism, you don't even understand the definition of it. Your definition was fucking funny, any atheist reading this would piss in his pants of laughting.

    The minority group in paganism are anarchists, there are way more nazi pagan than anarcho-pagans.

    I have asked you guys to prove your facts with links to anarchist paganist organizations, i have also asked you to post serious texts explaining links between anarchism and paganism. But you FAILED. I have posted many texts explaining that anarchists atheists are against paganism, i have also posted many texts explaining the link between paganism and fascism. But you still accuse me of not bringing up arguments but YOU are not brining up any argument that proves anything.

    So what ?

    All anarchist philosophers have bad points. Proudhon was a sexist and a mutuellist, nestor makhno was a platformist, subcommandante marcos is half marxist, noam chomsky defend nazism and negationism, kropotkin signed the manifesto of the 16, max stirner was an individualist, etc etc etc.

    You're just trying to find arguments to contradict me, you are pathetic. Emma goldman's bad point doesn't change anything in her great atheist anti-religious fight and philosophy.

    I'm an anarcho-synthesist. I take the good points in all philosphys to make my own opinion, so i can make the synthesis of Emma Goldman while not taking her "racism"

    Why are you talking about abolishing all religions when you are against it ?
     
  6. Bakica

    Bakica Experienced Member Experienced member Forum Member


    951

    0

    0

    Feb 21, 2010
     
    wow i finaly some arguing going around here :ecouteurs: haha
     
  7. Protspecd

    Protspecd Experienced Member Experienced member Forum Member


    466

    0

    0

    Mar 3, 2010
     
    I think he means from your perspective. To get what you want, abolishing all religions, *you* need to understand why they believe in their religion and then carefully nurture them to your way of thinking rather than abusing them into your beliefs. Think he was just telling you a better way of persuasion.

    Could be wrong though, that is how I read it anyways.
     
  8. Axehandle Mountain

    Axehandle Mountain Active Member Forum Member


    41

    0

    0

    Feb 26, 2010
     
    Do you really expect me to read every word you've posted after you clearly assumed that all pagans were Nazis, and then later decided to backtrack on those statements? You rambled about not reading fascist garbage or anything that you don't agree with, but you're whining because I'm adopting the same approach? It's impossible to debate with someone who argues like a child with points that defy logic. You don't understand atheism, paganism, or religion, but you believe you're an authority. I really doubt you understand anarchism. It's something more than catchphrases, nifty patches, and fighting against anything that doesn't coincide with your juvenile mall-punk mentality. This is the last time I'm going to address or read anything you post on this website. I't's a shame that you're a moderator and I can't place you on the "ignore" list. The admin should take some time to rethink your position.

    I'm done.
     
  9. WitchesHammer

    WitchesHammer Member Forum Member


    13

    0

    0

    Aug 25, 2009
     
    Paganism has been taken on by all kinds of people. From all walks of life someone may claim paganism. I can think of a few idiots that need to stop claiming anarchism.
    Paganism has nothing to do with national socialist black metal bands. National socialist black metal bands THINK they have something to do with paganism. Paganism finds it's roots in early humanity, when we were void of domestication. Paganism's views of "gods" and "goddesses" were constructed to bring personalities to the world around them. Pagans worship the earth. I might not be fully pagan (but then again noone is) but I sure as fuck see that there is a gift in each sunrise and I'm fucking lucky to have the earth under my feet. We answer to nature's will and are at her whim. You might disagree that paganism has anything to do with anarchism...but isn't there a reason that our circled a's don't extend outside of the circle? There are ideas behind the a that extends past the lines of the circle, and there are ideas behind the ones kept inside. There IS WITHOUT A DOUBT a natural ORDER to the world...and we are at it's beckon. We as a whole might do terrible things to our planet and at somepoints may feel empowered, but we are weak, and our earth is strong. Not to be a dick, but alot of anarchists I've run into over the years, most of them pretty well educated...are atleast somewhat familiar with paganism. I'm not talking wicca or new wave bullshit. I'm not talking black metal nazi's. I'm not talking the 13 year old that spouts off about practicing magic, and I'm not talking about the 13 year old that spouts off about chaos when he speaks of anarchism. We aren't stupid, and I don't think you are either. I would appreciate it if you could take the time to understand that paganism, in it's purest forms, offers us no oppression and does not bind us to dogmatic practices, rather, gives the world around us a personality so that it's actions may be better interepreted by our petty, small brains.
     
  10. WitchesHammer

    WitchesHammer Member Forum Member


    13

    0

    0

    Aug 25, 2009
     
     
  11. dwtcos

    dwtcos Experienced Member Experienced member Forum Member


    642

    1

    3

    Oct 22, 2009
     
    I wish people on this site would stop teenagers synonomously(sp?) with immature ignoramuses =_=
     
  12. WitchesHammer

    WitchesHammer Member Forum Member


    13

    0

    0

    Aug 25, 2009
     
    The nazi's stole an imporant pagan symbol, it never had any roots in that sort of ideaology. That would be like claiming I'm guilty of a hate crime because someone took my knife I use to cut my food to kill a black man.
     
  13. Anom

    Anom Experienced Member Experienced member Forum Member


    698

    0

    0

    Dec 21, 2009
     
    Since we have some bright teens among us here to prove that kind of comments to be plain wrong, i definately agree. Can't feel all that fun for them.
     
  14. ungovernable

    ungovernable Autonome Staff Member Uploader Admin Team Experienced member


    4,423

    119

    24

    Aug 21, 2009
    Male
    Canada  Canada
    Wow, you are a fucking idiot, i repeated it over 10 times : I NEVER SAID ALL PAGANS ARE NAZIS

    I said that there are WAY MORE nazi pagans than anarcho-pagans.

    I also asked you to link me to articles explaining links between anarchism and paganism and linking me to anarcho-pagans organizations. YOU FAILED.

    You really don't understand anything. First i never said i don't read fascist garbage, THIS IS ANOTHER INVENTION OF YOUR'S. I said that this forum is not the place for fascist propaganda just like it isn't the place for liberal or conservative propaganda. Am i a fascist, a liberal or a conservative ?

    BTW i said multiple time that i have read mein kampf so shut up with your bullshit and your lies, you are inventing stuff again

    You mean it's impossible to debate with someone who IGNORE your arguments like you are doing ?

    Now YOU are acting like a fascist. At least i consider your argument.

    Yeah right. How i don't understand atheism ? hahahah And how do i believe i'm an authority ? Wow you are really retarded

    Shut up ignorant religious fool, i was an anarchist before you even know what it stood for. You don't even know me, i'm an activist, not a dumbass who play in a shitty pagan band like you. You're the one whose fight is limited to the punk scene, i always said i am an anarchist BEFORE being a punk. You are the mall punk ;)

    Nothing new, you're already ignoring me, even if i bring up arguments you ignore them. You're acting like a fascist. What the fuck are you doing on a DEBATE FORUM if you refuse to debate with the ones not sharing your point of view ? That's typically religious indoctrination, debating with you or debating with a christian would be the same. You are brainwashed !

    hahahahahahhahahahahahahahahahahahhahahaa NO YOU'RE NOT AN ATHEIST !!!!!!!

    I think you have some mental problems dude, or maybe a double-personnality... You don't know what you are, you're confused and ignorant. And then you pretend that i am illeterate BUT IT'S YOU THE RETARD WHO IS ILLETERATE

    I copy your first post on this topic:
    At least you understand that you're so confused that your beliefs will change because you have been researching various pratices and beliefs (proof that you are confused and that you NEED something to believe in, you can't just be yourself you need to find an IDENTITY). One day you are not an atheist, and the second day you pretend you are an atheist

    YOU ARE THE ILLETERATE !!!

    Plus you refuse to question yourself, since the begginning you said you don't even read atheist opinions. YOU'RE ACTING LIKE A FASCIST, you want to live in your ideal world without considering anybody else's opinion. YOU are the one who doesn't understand anything about anarchism, you're not anarcho you're a religious brainwashed idiot.
     
  15. Axehandle Mountain

    Axehandle Mountain Active Member Forum Member


    41

    0

    0

    Feb 26, 2010
     
    I removed that contradictory sentence due to my poor choice of words, but it still holds truth. No, I don't accept the label of "atheist" and I'm open to thought about "God", but my personal opinions follow the thought Albert Einstein (you quote him), and by definition I am an atheist. God is not a being, it's a romantic description for the universe we're apart of.

    I'm not going to read the rest of your gibberish, I just wanted to correct myself for other people reading this discussion.
     
  16. ungovernable

    ungovernable Autonome Staff Member Uploader Admin Team Experienced member


    4,423

    119

    24

    Aug 21, 2009
    Male
    Canada  Canada
    it's not just about symbols, please explain how nazi paganist see links between this religion and their politic ideas, please explain why they even believe that a nationalist MUST be a pagan and vice-versa. did you even read the article called "the pagan roots of the fascist culture" ? fascism/nazism was built on paganism.

    and before some dumbass start inventing facts again, no i'm not saying that all pagans are nazis.


    Keep acting like a fascist.

    Why don't you leave this forum if you don't want to debate ? You don't accept other points of view, you're not an anarchist. I'm against your religion and at least i debate with you and consider your arguments. Why don't you join a fascist forum, at least there they only accept similar points of views, no place for difference. You registered here to talk only with peoples you agree with ?

    No you're not an atheist, atheist is being against all religions, AND PAGANISM IS BY DEFINITION A RELIGION

    At least you confirmed us that all pagans are closed-minded indoctrinated and brainwashed retards, you're not an exception to the rule since you ignore all arguments against your beliefs and you refuse to question yourself. Brainwashed and indoctrinated.
     
  17. WitchesHammer

    WitchesHammer Member Forum Member


    13

    0

    0

    Aug 25, 2009
     
    Capitalism is our enemy. Fascism is our enemy. The state is our enemy. The government is our enemy. The select few, elite rich families that control this world ARE OUR ENEMY.
    The earth, is not our enemy. Peaceful, earth centered worships based on furthering our understanding of the world around us and what WE CAN DO TO MAKE THIS A BETTER WORLD, is not our enemy. Of all the anarchists that have adopted a love for our planet and everything it has given us, of all of the anarchists that respect the animals on this planet and choose not to eat them, and of all of the anarchists that chain themselves to trees, cement themselves in the ground, and dig up logging roads to PROTECT THE WORLD AROUND US...YOU WOULD THINK IT WOULD BE OUR GOAL TO MAKE SURE THEIR STRIFE WASN'T IN VAIN, AND THAT OUR OWN ACTIONS TAKEN TO BETTER THIS WORLD WOULD NOT BE SQUANDERED AWAY BY IDEALISTIC VIEWS ABOUT WHAT IS AND IS NOT OK WITH YOU. For all that have given their lives and their love of this planet to better it...I thank you.

    Why are you an anarchist, is it because you believe in the posibility of bettering this world through consensus and cooperation and the decentralization of state, wealth, and power? Or is it because you just don't want to be told what to do?

    how do you feel about communes? walk into one, if you know where one's at...I sure as fuck do...and see how many anarchist pagans you find.
     
  18. Vegetarian Barbarian

    Vegetarian Barbarian Experienced Member Experienced member Forum Member


    719

    2

    0

    Oct 19, 2009
     
    IF YOU TWO CANT COME TO AGREE ON ANYTHING STOP FUCKING ARGUING!!! NOONE IS PERSUADING THE OTHER TO CHANGE THEIR MINDS ABOUT WHAT THEY BELIEVE ANYWAYS!!!!!!!!!!

    IF THE MAN WANTS TO BE A PAGAN, LET HIM. IS HE OUT KILLING MINORITIES? IS HE APART OF THE STATE OR THE GOVERNMENT? IS HE A COP? NO (assuming he isnt). NOW I PERSONALLY DISAGREE BUT LIKE I SAID BEFORE IF HE IS STILL A KIND AND DECENT BEING (supposedly), I HAVE NO RIGHT TO TELL HIM HIS WAY OF THINKING IS BULLSHIT (ON THIS ISSUE ANYWAYS)

    I also feel that everyone on here has a different definition of "anarchy", anarchists and what they are supposed to believe in. But the one thing they have in common is that they dont judge other people of the same type of governmental thinking for 1 or 2 slightly different views.

    Lets all be friends... means to an end
     
  19. colton_and

    colton_and Experienced Member Experienced member


    54

    1

    0

    Mar 24, 2010
     

    what?
    Someone who knows 10x more about the subject with obviously be able to write more than someone who doesn't. Just cause someone doesnt have as much as say as you what does that mean? most of what you talk about is off of the internet. So i guess your smarter cause u talk more. And if you you havent notices not everyone has almost 1000 posts so the chances are pretty high that you more about the subject then most people.
     
  20. ungovernable

    ungovernable Autonome Staff Member Uploader Admin Team Experienced member


    4,423

    119

    24

    Aug 21, 2009
    Male
    Canada  Canada
    Oh, so now you are finally admitting that anarchism have ennemies. And that to avoid being contradictory you must accept this "set of rules". Why? Probably because that's what anarchism stands for since over 200 years, probably also because the majority of anarchist theoricians are against capitalism, nationalism, state, government, etc...

    WELL GUESS WHAT ? Religion is also our enemy, 90% of anarchist theoricians agree with this fact and thats what anarchism stands for since over 200 years.

    And don't tell me you can be religious and anarchist because there are a few theoricians who agree with this

    Because if we follow your logic, all the "enemies" i have stated previously can also be anarchist

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anarcho-capitalism
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libertarianism
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National-Anarchism

    RELIGION IS OUR ENEMY, JUST LIKE CAPITALISM NATIONALISM AND STATE

    That's called ecologism and environementalism, NOT FUCKING STUPID RELIGIONS DOGMAS AND CULTS. You are confusing everything. Because anarchists respect the planet doesn't means they need a religion to do it.

    That's like saying anarchists are buddhists because they believe in peace and equality.

    You don't believe in not being told what to do when you agree to FOLLOW a religious CULT, a DOGMA, that tells you how to think how to act and what to believe in. Just be yourself, you don't need to identify yourself in religious identities

    Are you crazy or what ? I never saw a single anarchist pagan in a commune.
     
Loading...
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.